How To Avoid Shoulder Pain During an Overhead Press: 3 Easy Exercises for Overhead Press Relief

CrossFit athlete with shoulder pain during an overhead press

You’re about to press overhead… then that pinching sensation strikes again. You’re not alone. Shoulder pain during overhead lifts is super common—especially if your rotator cuff isn’t firing right. But what you do before you lift matters. Most folks skip prep and jump straight into the heavy sets. But here’s the truth: warming up the rotator cuff with purpose helps prevent shoulder pain and improves performance.

HERE are three simple, effective exercises you can do right before your press routine.


1. Shoulder External Rotation with Band (Elbows at Side)

What It Is
A foundational rotator cuff activation drill using a resistance band around the wrists—elbows tucked in, turning the hands outward.

Why Most People Skip It (and Why It Fails You)
Ever jump into presses without cueing your external rotators? That’s like running a race without tying your shoes. You may feel stable—but underneath, your shoulder isn’t aligned, often resulting in that familiar pinch.

What Actually Works

  • Loop a band around your wrists.
  • Keep elbows tight to your ribs.
  • Externally rotate by pulling hands outward.
  • Control it, hold for 2 seconds at the end range.
  • Do 2–3 sets of 10–15 reps per side.

This lights up your rotator cuff, primes stability, and prepares your shoulder capsule for heavier lifts.


2. Isometric External Rotation with Front Raise

What It Is
A static hold that builds shoulder stability while promoting rotator cuff co-activation—with a front-arm raise included to challenge control.

What Most People Try (and Why It Falls Short)
Skipping isometrics and going straight to dynamic pressing works your muscles, sure—but it doesn’t train your shoulder to resist that pinching force at critical angles.

What Actually Works

  • Loop a band around both wrists.
  • Pull outward into the band—no motion, just tension.
  • Simultaneously raise both arms to shoulder height, keeping elbows bent to 90 degrees.
  • Hold for 2-3 seconds, then return to starting position.
  • Do 2 sets per side.

This builds resilience in the rotator cuff and improves dynamic control during overhead movements.


3. Isometric External Rotation with Overhead Press

What It Is
An advanced variation of the isometric drill—rotator cuff activation meets stability at the top of the range.

Why People Skip It (and Miss Out)
Shoulders often feel “fine” pressing, until they don’t. Skipping this step means missing the opportunity to train your stabilizers where they count most—above your head.

What Actually Works

  • Same band setup around wrists.
  • Lift arms overhead (as if pressing invisible dumbbells overhead).
  • Keep tension outward into the band—no elbow flare.
  • Hold for 2-3 seconds, then repeat.
  • Complete 2 sets of 8-12 reps.

This one reinforces end-range rotator cuff strength—critical for safe and pain-free pressing.


Why These Work Better Than Stretching

  • They activate stabilizers, not just warm up big movers.
  • They improve motor control, teaching your shoulder to maintain alignment.
  • They’re quick—perfect for pre-gym prep without wasting time- so you can get to your lifts and avoid shoulder pain.

Total Pursuit’s Green Bay Approach

At Total Pursuit Physical Therapy & Performance in Green Bay, we see how tiny habits in warm-up make a massive difference—especially for active adults who press, pull, climb, and live active lives. Unlike insurance-limited clinics, we focus on 1-on-1 form correction, custom progression, and root-cause solutions tailored just for you.

  • Custom warm-up routines based on your needs
  • Hands-on feedback during sessions
  • Tools like our Root Cause Reinforcement System™ to make these drills stick

Success Story: Shoulder Pain to Overhead Confidence

Last month, Sarah—a CrossFit enthusiast—walked in frustrated by shoulder pain during push presses. She’d tried stretching, rest, even ice—with minimal change. We introduced these three drills right before every lift. After two weeks, her pinch was gone, and she was reclaiming overhead confidence—without cutting back on training volume.


Final Thoughts: Don’t Wait Until It Escalates

Stop letting shoulder pinches ruin your pressing session. These three simple exercises take just 5 minutes—and they target why the pain shows up, not just masking it.

Don’t wait until it escalates. Build a smarter warm-up habit—and lift with stability, strength, and confidence.

📍Based in Green Bay and need help with overhead lifts?


👉 Schedule a free shoulder screen today. Let’s build the foundations for your press—without pain.

Dr. Matt Buch and Family

Get to know

Dr. Matt Buch

PT, DPT, OCS

As a doctor of physical therapy, my role in healthcare is to diagnose and treat injuries of the musculoskeletal system, assess movement, and optimize performance. My passion is to help outdoor enthusiasts maintain and enhance their active lifestyle without unnecessary medications, injections, or surgery.

Whether you are gearing up for the hunt of a lifetime, recovering from a climbing injury, or just trying to keep up with your grandkids, everyone is in pursuit of something.

I am here to help you achieve your goals and return to living the life that you desire.

Success Stories

Real Results from
Real Patients

Don’t take our word for it — hear from people just like you.

EXCELLENT
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Based on 123 reviews
Posted on Google Google
Devan Pavlicek profile picture
Devan Pavlicek
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I saught out a PT after a reaggravated a long term back injury in an attempt to properly address the issue and come out with a long term recovery plan. After working with Matt for the last couple months, I can wholeheartedly say it was the best decision I made and I cannot recommend Matt enough. From day one, we sat down and assessed the injury and came up with a gameplan. I made clear my intentions and what I was looking for and Matt listened and outlined a complete timeline of what he looked to do each session, and summarized the recovery from start to finish. Throughout the process, he was always intently looking to me for feedback to ensure I was getting everything I was looking for and inquiring if I wanted to pivot or tweak the scope of a session. Not only is Matt extremely attentive, he's very communicative and willing to give video feedback in real time and correct form/technique to better serve you in long term recovery. Dont hesitate to give Matt and Total Pursuit a try!
Posted on Google Google
Aaron Berger profile picture
Aaron Berger
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
If you are thinking about going anywhere else, don’t. Dr. Matt is awesome. He will work with you in all aspects of your recovery and get you back to where you want to be and more! I went to Dr. Matt for pre-treatment for my upcoming Shoulder surgery. After only three days, I was at 90% rotation and no pain whatsoever and back on my feet. The work we did previous to my surgery has decreased my recovery by months!
Posted on Google Google
Clint Reed profile picture
Clint Reed
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I went to see Dr.Matt after struggling with shoulder and bicep pain in my right arm. I had very limited use of my right arm without pain. Dr. Matt assessed my concern.we came up with a game plan on treatment, and within a couple weeks I regained 90% of the motion back without any pain. I am confident that when our treatment plan wraps up I will have full motion completely pain free.
Posted on Google Google
Steve Roth profile picture
Steve Roth
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I’ve had the chance to get to know Dr. Matt Buch through our local networking group, and he’s someone who really stands out for his character and integrity. Matt is the kind of person who is genuine, honest, and always looking to do right by others. He shows up consistently, supports the people around him, and brings a high level of professionalism to everything he does. You can tell he truly cares about helping people and takes pride in his work. Even though I haven’t personally used his services, I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him based on the way he carries himself and the reputation he’s built. If you’re looking for someone you can trust, Matt and Total Pursuit are a great choice.
Posted on Google Google
Wes profile picture
Wes
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I was born with infant torticollis and I had neck and middle back pains along with my hips needing to be adjusted. Been going to the chiropractor for 16 years and I feel way more relief now that I have been seeing Dr. Matt. Even after this huge blizzard we just had, I would normally feel a lot of lower back pain and I had minimal soreness after shoveling and snow blowing the last couple days. Would highly recommend! 👍🏻
Posted on Google Google
Jonathan Valdez profile picture
Jonathan Valdez
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I needed help. Had a bad sciatic episode this past winter where walking was a chore. With Dr buch's expertise and the exercises we worked on, I was able to enjoy the latter part of the ice fishing season pain free. A true professional, and a student of his craft, I would highly recommend total pursuit to anyone dealing with musculoskeletal issues. Thank you Matt!
Posted on Google Google
Kymberly Klimek profile picture
Kymberly Klimek
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Dr. Matt is an exceptional physical therapist who deeply cares about his patients and their outcomes. Our viewpoints align well because he takes the time to perform thorough evaluations, identify the root cause of injuries, and create personalized treatment plans that help people recover faster, move better, and stay active doing the things they enjoy most. If you’re dealing with pain, recovering from an injury, or looking to improve performance, Dr. Matt will give you his very best to help you get back to doing what you love. Your body will thank you for seeing Dr. Matt and the team at Total Pursuit Physical Therapy & Performance. Highly recommend them!
Posted on Google Google
Randy Paff profile picture
Randy Paff
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Matt customized my therapy to really fit my progress and goals. I could not sleep on my shoulder and was in pain with simple tasks such as putting on a jacket or backpack. I am nearly pain free now and my strength is coming back as well. I am 61 and again participating in activities I thought I may have to give up such as bow hunting. Thanks Matt
Posted on Google Google
Kurt Niska profile picture
Kurt Niska
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Dr Matt is exceptional! I herniated two discs in my lower back and went through 8 months of insurance approved PT through my doctor, including three rounds of steroid treatments (two oral and one spinal). While I certainly had made progress and appreciated the care I received, I had no idea how to avoid injury again or what to do next. After months of searching, I met Dr Matt at a wellness event and booked a consultation. How wonderful to find someone willing to guide an ordinary Joe to strengthen and rehabilitate beyond simply being functional! Dr Matt is patient, responsive, thorough, and clearly explains what we’re doing and how it applies. Thank you, Dr Matt, for helping me get stronger and regain confidence in what my body is capable of doing. I know my journey is not complete but I am grateful to have you and your expertise in my corner.
Posted on Google Google
Brandon Harrell profile picture
Brandon Harrell
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I went to see Dr. Matt after struggling with back issues for years and finding little relief through traditional treatments. From the initial assessment, he took a thorough and thoughtful approach. Instead of just addressing symptoms, he focused on improving strength and stability in the areas surrounding my back that had been neglected due to long-term pain. The results have been tremendous. I’m stronger, more stable, and finally moving in the right direction. I highly recommend Dr. Matt to anyone dealing with ongoing issues.
Verified by Trustindex
Trustindex verified that these reviews were published on Total Pursuit Physical Therapy & Performance's Google Business Profile. Learn more

Monday – Thursday

7 am to 7 pm

Friday

7 am to 4 pm

Scroll to Top
Free guide for active adults in Green Bay.

The Gym Goers Secret: 4 Drills for Pain-Free Lifts

The Gym Goer's Secret: 4 Drills for Pain Free Lifting

Unlock Performance, Prevent Injury, Live Without Setbacks